Official Development Assistance (ODA)
3. ODA Country Policy toward Major Recipients
Japan's ODA in Pakistan
1. Basic Policies
(1) Pakistan's Position in Japan's ODA
Japan is providing assistance to Pakistan, taking into account the following factors.
1) | Pakistan plays an important political and economic role in Southwest Asia and also among the Islamic countries and maintains traditionally friendly relations with Japan. Also, Japan is Pakistan's largest trade partner. |
2) | While confronted with difficult social and economic problems, including a high population growth rate, a low literacy rate, growing unemployment, energy shortages, and persistent budget and trade deficits, Pakistan is actively pursuing domestic development and is therefore in great need of assistance. |
3) | In recent years, in the framework of resource diplomacy, Pakistan is increasing great geopolitical importance as the gateway to the countries of central Asia. |
4) | Pakistan has been promoting various forms of deregulation in recent years, including economic liberalization and privatization of state-owned enterprises, and the new government of Nawaz Sharif, formed in February 1997, stated its intention to further promote these policies. |
However, in May 1998, Pakistan conducted its first underground nuclear tests, in response to India's same tests. Japan responded by strongly urging Pakistan to call off its testing and development of nuclear weapons and halting all new grant aid (with the exception of aid of an emergency and humanitarian character and grant assistance for grassroots projects) and new yen loans, in accordance with Japan's ODA Charter.
Pakistan is the seventh largest recipient of Japanese bilateral aid (based on cumulative net disbursements up to 1998).
(2) Priority Areas for Japan's ODA
On the basis of studies and research concerning development conditions, tasks, and development plans in Pakistan, as well as policy dialogues between Japan and Pakistan, including the High-Level Mission on Economic and Technical Cooperation sent to Pakistan from February to March 1996 and subsequent policy dialogues, Japan has given priority to assistance in the areas described below.
1) | Social sector Emphasizing support for the Social Action Program (SAP), which is aimed at strengthening approaches to problems in the social sector, assistance in the educational field will place particular emphasis on raising the level of basic education and primary education for girls. Cooperation on human resources development that focuses on the health and medical fields, including such areas as population control and AIDS prevention, as well as the improvement of the living environment, given present conditions such as poor water and sewage systems. |
2) | Economic infrastructure Promoting assistance to upgrade the basic economic infrastructure that is impeding economic development in Pakistan. Assistance includes the electrification of farming villages and the improvement of the efficiency of electric power facilities in light of the present situation in which the demand for electric power is surpassing the supply. Other assistance is being provided for the building and repair of national and local roads, train facilities and vehicular repair in order to enhance the transportation network. |
3) | Agriculture Agriculture is a key industry in Pakistan, accounting for approximately 25 percent of GDP and employing 50 percent of the total working population. However, agricultural productivity is extremely low, and therefore boosting productivity and ensuring a stable food supply are matters of the greatest urgency. Although approximately 80 percent of Pakistan's arable land is irrigated and it has one of the highest levels of irrigation in the world, the irrigation facilities have become obsolete. Thus, Japan will provide assistance to upgrade, expand, maintain, manage, and repair existing irrigation facilities in places where the agricultural infrastructure, including irrigation facilities, is underdeveloped, and to support agricultural research. |
4) | Environmental conservation The Pakistani government has gained a strong understanding in recent years of the need for protection of the natural environment and pollution control, and is taking steps, including the establishment of the Environment Protection Bureau. It is promoting assistance aimed at the prevention of industrial pollution and combating environmental problems such as erosion, flooding, and desertification, which are the result of increasing deforestation as well as the deterioration of urban environments. |
(3) Matters for Consideration
- Consistency and transparency of policy are essential to Pakistan's development policies and plans. There is also need for support to improve implementation capabilities through the fostering of human resources in Pakistani implementing organizations.
- There is room for greater utilization of Japanese technical cooperation by Pakistan. In addition to combining technical and capital cooperation, there is a need to strengthen the participation of NGOs and international aid organizations and consider assistance to the socially vulnerable and WID (women in development).
- In order to build a sound financial base, there is a need for reform of the tax collection system and reform of the economic structure, beginning with the privatization of the power industry. There is also need to consider measures for the development of a sound financial system and for the building of an investment environment that meet the conditionalities of the IMF and the World Bank.
(4) The Situation Regarding the ODA Charter
In light of serious international and domestic concern regarding the possibility of Pakistan developing nuclear capability, Japan held bilateral consultations with Pakistan on nuclear non-proliferation and aid policy dialogues, urging Pakistan to exercise self-restraint. Using these and other opportunities, Japan has expressed its concerns to Pakistan, continuing to urge Pakistan to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT). Japan has also sought greater transparency in Pakistan's nuclear-related programs.
In May 1998, India conducted nuclear tests; Japan, through the dispatch of a prime ministerial envoy, urged Pakistan to exercise the maximum self-restraint. The same month, however, Pakistan conducted its own nuclear test. Japan called on Pakistan immediately to cease both its nuclear weapons tests and the development of nuclear weapons and to unconditionally sign the NPT and the CTBT. Japan also took measures to stop all new grant aid (with the exception of aid of an emergency and humanitarian nature and grant assistance for grassroots projects) and all new yen loans, and announced it would adopt a cautious attitude toward multilateral development bank loans to Pakistan.
At the June 1998 G8 foreign ministers' meeting, participating countries decided to postpone deliberations on funding to Pakistan in areas other than basic human needs assistance through international financial bodies such as the World Bank. This, in addition to economic measures applied by the major countries created a rapid worsening in Pakistan's already unstable economic situation. In February 1999, Pakistani Prime Minister Sharif announced the Lahore Declaration at the India-Pakistan summit meeting, reducing tensions with India and setting the stage for the building of trust between the two countries. During the November 1998 visit of the Pakistani foreign minister to Japan, there was a clear statement of intention regarding two issues: signing of the CTBT and the creation of a law that would restrict the export of missile parts and nuclear technology from Pakistan. Japan joined with other G8 member countries in supporting emergency support measures through the IMF in recognition of Pakistan's economic distress. In light of Pakistan's efforts, Japan will continue to monitor the situation and consider the resumption of bilateral economic cooperation, although Japan once again asked Pakistan to exercise self-restraint after its April 1999 mid-range ballistic missile tests.
2. The Current Economic Situation in Pakistan and Tasks to Be Addressed
(1) Major Economic Indicators
1997 per capita GNP and GNP growth rates (1990-1997 average) |
Real GDP growth rate | ||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
$500; 2.0% (World Bank figures) |
|
(2) Current Situation
The Sharif government placed priority on reviving the economy and increasing agricultural production through mid-term policies that would promote industry, including tax reductions and increase the price at which the government purchases wheat. In November 1997, the government announced new investment policies that provided tax incentives and opened most sectors to foreign investment. On the other hand, chronic shortages of foreign currency and the halting of financing and assistance through international financial bodies and donor countries as a result of its May 1998 nuclear tests, put Pakistan in a precarious economic situation. In September 1998, Prime Minister Sharif announced at the UN that Pakistan would sign the CTBT by September 1999. As a result, the IMF announced a support package to Pakistan, the World Bank resumed structural adjustment financing and Pakistan was able to reschedule $3.3 billion in debt repayments under the Paris Club and to avoid deepening its economic troubles. Pakistan must now, in addition to meeting the conditionalities of the IMF, undertake the reform of its economy.
(3) Tasks to Be Addressed
- Implementing fiscal reform, including tax reform and curtailment of non-development expenditures
- Controlling inflation
- Continuing economic liberalization through deregulation in various areas and privatization
- Strengthening the international competitiveness of industry
- Reducing the trade deficit
- Implementing measures to alleviate poverty and controlling the high population growth rate
- Enhancing social services such as education, and health and medical services
- Upgrading the economic infrastructure, including the areas of electric power and transportation
- Boosting agricultural productivity in order to achieve a stable, self-sufficient food supply
3. Development Programs
The Ninth Five-Year Plan had not yet been announced as of July 1999. For reference, the previous five-year plan is below.
Goals:
- Improving social and economic welfare
Main tasks:
- Alleviating poverty, achieving economic independence, creating jobs and protecting the environment
Major targets:
- Average annual GDP growth rate: 7%
- Budget deficit/GDP ratio: 4.3%
- Savings/GDP ratio: 20.5%
Specific measures:
- Investment: Place emphasis on private-sector investment. Public investment priorities are given to human resources and infrastructure development.
- Fiscal measures: Increase the weight of direct taxation and cut back on subsidies.
- Balance of payments: Expand exports of textile goods, light-industry products, and sporting goods.
- Key sectors: Agriculture, manufacturing, energy, transportation and communications, and social services.
Pakistan's 2010 Plan (comprehensive long-term plan announced in February 1992) - Doubling the per capita national income to $1000
- Attaining an annual income growth rate of 5.2%, reducing the population growth rate to 2.2% and obtaining a GDP growth rate of 7.4%
- Conversion of industries to export-oriented industries
4. Aid Statistics
(1) Japanese Assistance
Calendar Year | ODA Loans | Grant Aid | Technical Cooperation | Total | Rank of Total Contribution |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1998 | 424 | 57 | 14 | 495 | 5th |
Cumulative through 1998 | 2,541 | 1,038 | 225 | 3,804 | 7th |
(2) Assistance from DAC Countries
Total Bilateral Aid | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
---|---|---|---|
73 | Japan: 92 | United Kingdom: 43 | Netherlands: 17 |
(3) ODA from International Organizations
Total Aid | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
---|---|---|---|
536 | ADB: 220 | IDA: 191 | IMF: 36 |
Japan's ODA in Sri Lanka
1. Basic Policies
(1) Sri Lanka's Position in Japan's ODA
Japan provides assistance to Sri Lanka, taking into account the following factors.
1) | Sri Lanka has long had amicable relations with Japan. |
2) | Since the country's independence in 1948, Sri Lanka has been a democracy with democratically-elected governments. Sri Lanka is also making its own efforts at economic reform by implementing structural adjustment measures. |
3) | While development is progressing, particularly in urban areas, the country has a substantial need for assistance in economic development, including infrastructure and regional development. |
Sri Lanka is the 9th largest recipient of Japan's bilateral aid (based on cumulative net disbursements up to 1998), and Japan is the largest provider of assistance to Sri Lanka.
(2) Priority Areas for Japan's ODA
On the basis of studies and research concerning development conditions and tasks in Sri Lanka and its development plans, as well as policy dialogues between Japan and Sri Lanka, including the High-Level Mission on Economic and Technical Cooperation sent to Sri Lanka in March 1991 and subsequent policy dialogues, Japan has given priority to assistance in the following areas.
1) | Building and improving economic infrastructure To promote industry, Sri Lanka needs to improve its underdeveloped infrastructure, including transportation, power and communications. Cooperation is being provided to build nationwide networks, although the focus remains on the areas around Colombo. Development of Sri Lanka's southern area is being pursued in a planned fashion from a long-term perspective. Consideration is also being given to social infrastructure, including water and sewage facilities. |
2) | Development of mining and manufacturing industries Given the scale of Sri Lanka's domestic markets, building export-oriented industries is the key to the country's development; thus, assistance is being provided to mining and manufacturing industries as well as to promote trade which would lead to greater employment. Particular emphasis is given to assistance in development plans for industries with prospects for development, as well as industrial estates, and technical cooperation to improve productivity and quality. Particular emphasis is given to promoting assistance in development plans for industries with prospects for development, as well as industrial estates, and technical cooperation to improve productivity and quality. Assistance is also being given to small- and medium-sized businesses to reduce unemployment and increase employment opportunities for women to play more active roles in society. |
3) | Development of agriculture, forestry, and fisheries Sri Lanka places priority on its agricultural development on improved self-sufficiency in basic foodstuffs, as well as on increasing employment opportunities and income in rural areas. Japan therefore provides assistance in improving agricultural infrastructure, including rehabilitation of existing irrigation facilities, promotion of agro-industries, the building of markets and distribution routes, the spread of agricultural research and promoting coastal fisheries. |
4) | Human resources development Sri Lanka has a particularly severe need for quantitative and qualitative improvements in higher education, as well as a need to foster mid-level officials in administrative institutions in order to build the human resources required for social and economic development. Japan is therefore endeavoring to achieve even more effective assistance, through steps that include accepting trainees and sending experts, in addition to improvement in the educational environment. |
5) | Improving health and medical services Regional health and medical services systems in Sri Lanka are still in need of improvement. Given these and other circumstances, Japan is providing assistance to upgrade provincial hospitals and central hospitals for rural areas, as well as to improve diagnostic techniques and medical equipment maintenance technologies. Japan is also providing assistance to train personnel such as medical inspectors and nurses. Japan is also examining measures to control oral propagation of infectious diseases. |
In addition to the above five areas, priority has been placed on the environment in recent years, with assistance provided for waste disposal and improving the living environment.
(3) Matters for Consideration
In December 1995, the Sri Lankan Army quelled resistance in the western part of the North Jaffna Peninsula (including the city of Jaffna) which is the base of operations for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). Since that time, however, the dispute has continued with sporadic battles in the north and east, and bomb attacks by LTTE activists in Colombo and the surrounding area that have targeted political figures, army and police facilities, and key economic institutions. While such terrorist acts are not directed at the foreign community, it is nonetheless necessary for Japan to take steps to consider measures to ensure that experts and JOCV volunteers in Sri Lanka do not become victims of such acts. Since May 1995, the entire Jaffna peninsula has been placed under Sri Lankan army control, and the government has called on donors to assist in rebuilding this area. Japan continues to examine what support is feasible for this area, while continuing to monitor the substantial public safety problem.
(4) The Situation Regarding the ODA Charter
The government of Sri Lanka is making efforts to protect and improve human rights. Nevertheless, Japan will continue to monitor the human rights situation in the strife-torn northern and eastern regions.
2. The Current Economic Situation in Sri Lanka and Tasks to Be Addressed
(1) Major Economic Indicators
1997 per capita GNP and GNP growth rates (1990-1997 average) |
Real GDP growth rate | ||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
$800; 4.0% (World Bank figures) |
|
(2) Current Situation
Sri Lanka has been moving forward with structural reforms including privatization, such as the private capital investment in Sri Lanka Telecom (in August 1998, NTT purchased 35% of the company's shares and is participating in management) and the partial sale of shares in Air Lanka (in April 1998). There was concern that the influence on the fiscal deficit of the increase in military spending to deal with internal conflicts would have a negative effect on external business, but with the help of earnings from the privatization of national enterprises in 1999 the fiscal deficit as a ratio of GDP dropped to 4.5% in 1997 from 7.8% in 1996, although it rose once again to 9.2% of GDP in 1998. The GDP growth rate recovered from 3.8% in 1996 to 6.4% in 1997, while the inflation rate fell to 9.6% in 1997 (from 15.9% in 1996). Overall economic activity is steady, although it slowed in 1998 due to the effects of the Asian economic crisis.
(3) Tasks to Be Addressed
- Bringing about national peace through a peaceful settlement of the conflict in the northern and eastern regions
- Reducing the fiscal deficit and continuing structural adjustment efforts, including the privatization of state enterprises
- Creating better investment conditions, including improved social and economic infrastructure for expanding private investment from abroad
3. Development Programs
Five-Year Public Investment Plan (1997-2001)
Major Targets:
- GDP growth rate (annual average): 7.0%
- Per-capita income growth rate (annual average): 4.8%
- Inflation rate (annual average): from 15.9% in 1996 to 5.5% in the year 2001
- Budget deficit/GDP ratio: from approximately 8.9% in 1996 to 4.0% in the year 2001
- Unemployment: from 11% in 1996 to 5.0% in the year 2001
4. Aid Statistics
(1) Japanese Assistance
Calendar Year | ODA Loans | Grant Aid | Technical Cooperation | Total | Rank of Total Contribution |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1998 | 121 | 52 | 24 | 198 | 8th |
Cumulative through 1998 | 1,505 | 978 | 341 | 2,823 | 9th |
(2) Assistance from DAC Countries
Total Bilateral Aid | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
---|---|---|---|
228 | Japan: 135 | United Kingdom: 17 | Norway: 16 |
(3) ODA from International Organizations
Total Aid | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
---|---|---|---|
119 | ADB: 79 | IDA: 68 | UNDP: 8 |